Are you surprised I even remembered my login to the blog? Well, don’t be because I didn’t.
I find it very hard to write creatively or write at all when I’m not experiencing a depressed or manic episode, and life has been pretty okay recently, so writing hasn’t been something I’ve been too capable of as of late. However, this Friday in the wee hours of the morning I listened to the damn Tortured Poet’s Department by our lord and savior T Swift and damn it if she didn’t transport me right back to where I was the last time I felt hopelessly tortured myself.
The reason I’m writing today isn’t to smile and wave or brag about the fact that I don’t want to curl up in a ball and cry right now (thanks, Prozac), but rather that I’ve seen so many people, fans and critics alike, slander The Tortured Poets Department as ‘boring’ or ‘dramatic’ or ‘too much’ and all that has been ringing in my head is ‘fuck I wish I thought that…must be nice having never experienced your own personal torture by a low-grade Matty Healy or a corporate-office Kim Kardashian.’
As someone with depression and anxiety and the need to overachieve (or at the very least, achieve at all) and the inability to process hurt without writing dramatic poetry about it, this album resonated with me in a way that other albums don’t always do. Sure, I’m writing from my quaint (read: sketchy as hell) apartment, having just got off the phone with my wonderful boyfriend and studying for law school exams, but if I peel that situationally healed persona back, I still am the girl who absolutely broke over a situation-ship at 22 and wrote and wrote and wrote for years on end trying to get over some shit-ass Matty Healy-type tortured poet and I truly believe I’m better for it. (Even if I haven’t written a poem since.)
Moving on from that sad fact and the dozens of unfinished notes in my phone, (maybe I’ll finish some on a procrastination spree one day, you never know) I want to provide my objective top ten on the best TTPD songs. Since some friends and family who once read my blog aren’t particularly TS fans, I think it serves right to provide not my favorite songs from the album, but the ones that I find most resonating, most brilliant, most devastating. I don’t think I can fairly ‘rank’ them, but here are my ten suggestions:
- The Manuscript
- This song doesn’t resonate with any personal life experience of mine, but the story is painted so poignantly that you’re forced to experience empathy for the young girl in the story, and the blunt phrasing in the verses just adds to the art of this song.
- Themes: Grooming, longing, growing out of pain, sharing the story
- Highlight Lyric: “And at last She knew what the agony had been for” (I don’t want to spoil the last lyric of this song so I’m not selecting that)
- Fortnight
- No one can convince me this song isn’t about true crime. The way I see it, this song is an affair between two people, and the female counterpart wants to kill her husband because he is cheating and her muse’s wife because she is in the way. (I swear I just listened to a podcast about this and I cannot place which case it was. If you have any ideas comment below for a girl’s sanity.)
- Themes: Murder, white picket fence life, affairs
- Highlight Lyric: “All my mornings are Mondays/Stuck in an endless February”
- I Look In People’s Windows
- This is (I believe) the shortest song on the album, but boy does it paint a picture. This song illustrates what it is like to look in from The Outside (if you are a Swift fan, think of it as a grown up, darker “The Outside”) and to haunted by the desire to see someone or experience one thing one more time.
- Themes: Voyeurism of sorts, longing, what-if syndrome
- Highlight Lyric: “I attend Christmas parties from outside”
- The Prophecy
- This song is a prayer, a desperate plea, that feeling of begging an unknown being to help you and make things feel just a little bit better. This is one of the many songs that touch on religious metaphors and hits a little different for someone who has begged the powers-that-be the change the prophecy.
- Themes: Bargaining, begging, hoping, loneliness, destiny/fate
- Highlight Lyric: “I’m just a paperweight in shades of greige/Spending my last coin so someone will tell me it’ll be okay”
- But Daddy I Love HIm
- This song may not resonate with everyone but the humor, the cleverness, the tonge-in-cheek remarks that resonate towards a sort of suburban-drama, guilty-pleasure type of nonsense is something that a true writer and trope-absorber can truly appreciate.
- Themes: Scandal, tropes, humor, drama, gossip, breaking the fourth wall
- Highlight Lyric: I’ll tell you something about my good name/It’s mine alone to disgrace/I don’t cater to all these vipers dressed in empath’s clothing
- Clara Bow
- This song is an inward look at what the music industry is like for young women. Comparing icons of various time periods who were all plucked in their prime and told that they looked like ‘Insert Pretty Woman Here’ but ‘better’ and how fleeting that experience is for the ladies of the industry.
- Themes: Fame, girlhood, comparison, beauty, staying relevant
- Highlight Lyric: “Only when your girlish glow/Flickers just so/Do they let you know/it’s hell on earth to be heavenly”
- Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me?
- While a lot of these songs are autobiographical, this one is a deeper look at what Taylor’s experience has been over the years where she has been caged, trained, and presented like an animal, and expected to perform at the snap of one’s fingers. The vocals on this song are incredibly raw and highlight an emotion T doesn’t usually let come through quite as much in the studio versions of her songs.
- Themes: Being controlled, being influenced, the effects of being ‘on’ 24/7
- Highlight Lyric: “I was tame, I was gentle ’til the circus life made me mean/Don’t you worry folks, we took out all her teeth”
- Loml
- This song was a big question-mark going into the album, and many speculated that the acronym meant ‘loss of my life’ and boy were they right. This is one of the most heart-breaking songs on the record and establishes how embarrassing, haunting, lingering, and conflicting the pain of a loss can be and it is so well articulated that it had to be on this objective list.
- Themes: Loss, confusion, frustration, pain
- Highlight Lyric: “Dancing phantoms on the terrace/Are they second-hand embarrassed/That I can’t get out of bed/Cause something counterfeit’s dead”
- The Black Dog
- This song is one of the most pleasantly melodic and heartbreaking and cinematic songs on the record. I’m not sure if my personal love for this song is what landed it on this objective list, but it is a damn good song and I cannot get over it. It is perfection.
- Themes: Feeling foolish, internalized demons, raw pain
- Highlight Lyric: “Were you making fun of me with some esoteric joke?/Now I want to sell my house and set fire to all my clothes/And hire a priest to come and exorcise my demons/Even if I die screaming
- The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived
- If you want to understand why some men hate Taylor Swift, just listen to this song and here how eloquently she destroys The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived using the most established vocabulary and word-smithing in modern music. This is the type of song that makes me want to write and makes me want to be creative.
- Themes: Betrayal, anger, hurt, the last word
- Highlight Lyric: “Were you writing a book? Were you a sleeper-cell spy? In fifty years will all this be declassified?”
- HONORABLE MENTION/Karina’s Bonus Pick: Down Bad
- Is this song the best lyrical song on the album? Probably not. Is it the first song that resonated with me because it was a perfect, petulant example of what it is like to date your off-brand Matty Healy and be taken into the cosmos for the shortest spurt of time? Absolutely. For those of you that aren’t Swifties, this song is a metaphor where the narrator is essentially abducted by aliens and experiences a cosmic love (think love-bombing by the UniqueTM guy and promptly ghosted and hurt after they give you the most beautiful experience.
- Themes: Petulance, anger, frustration, galactic love
- Highlight Lyric: “How dare you think it’s romantic/Leaving me safe and stranded/’Cause fuck it, I was in love/So fuck you if I can’t have us
So non-swifties, if you appreciate good writing and can look past the Basic BitchTM trope that those who even click around near a Taylor Swift song receive, check out the songs above or the whole damn album. And swifties? Tell me what song would receive your objective award for Best Song (and also your personal fave.)
Adios for now! (See you soon or 3-4 years from now!)
KT